Monday, November 01, 2004

 

Cronycracy Will Not Work


Seeking Solutions (5)
Where do we want to go? (iii)

A lot has been said about bringing democracy to Iraq and to the Middle East. It has been said that democracy is the best safeguard for security and stability in this volatile corner of the world which holds lands sacred to many people around the world… and oil, sacred to modern civilization.

This is a noble cause of course. It would do wonders to this part of the world… if it is the right kind of democracy!

Democracy as I understand it (and I hope that you agree) is government by the people! (In Iraq, we have the additional requirement that government by the majority must not lead to "democratic" oppression of our multitude of minorities – but more on that later).

Democracy, for so many people in the States, sometimes seems to mean government by friends of the US government; cronycracy! This may sound far fetched, but look at what the US administration has been doing in trying to achieve "democracy" in Iraq.

This mentality is a remnant from the cold war that prevails in the US establishment. Many obnoxious systems of government loyal or friendly to the US are regarded as tolerable and sometimes even good. President George W. Bush said this clearly in one of his speeches a couple of years ago. At the time, I hoped that he meant to rectify the situation. Every political maneuver in Iraq since the invasion confirms that the old view prevails. Another lie? More probably institutional doctrine.

Every effort made by the US government to try and stabilize Iraq through political means has failed, and will continue to fail, because of this view of democracy. Well, it is immoral of course. It is also wrong in that it will lead to disasters. Why? People will simply resist it. Germany, Japan and Korea? There are so many differences… some of them have been referred to earlier. This is a long story.

To tell you the truth, I can live with cronycracy for a while if the system is designed to move to a democracy sometime. In Iraq the prospect of that happening is slim for a number of reasons:

Some of the people used in the US-engineered cronycracy are corrupt. There are several regional powers that are funding numerous political groups. Some of these groups do not have the welfare of Iraq as a priority. What's worse, these various groups are entrusted with the design of the system of elections. They will simply entrench. You can see that in every piece of legislation implemented in Iraq so far.

Therefore the system designed will not lead ultimately to democracy.




Comments:

Circular has nothing constructive to say.

I’ve been Googling "Iraq Constitutional Assembly" to try to find out what these January elections are meant to achieve. Unfortunately all I got was a speech by Dick Cheney, which was not really what I was after - my computer is rather basic and I haven’t got a Sewerage Protector. (Sorry. Surge.) But he did seem to confirm my understanding that the Assembly is intended just to discuss a Constitution, any implementation of actual "democracy" is still a year away at least, till then you’re stuck with cronycracy. Have I got that right?
If so, it sounds a very suitable forum in which to address the questions you have been raising, and you presumably will be making urgent submissions, with a lot of help from your Internet Advisors.
But doesn’t it just put us back in the "let’s pretend its not burning" situation, not just in Abu’s Blog but in respect of the Assembly itself?
My fear is that in a year’s time Iraq will be a very different place from the one we know and love today - either in a state of ultimate anarchy, with the "liberators" having gone home to recuperate, or so "shell shocked" into submission that it will be in effect a PTSD state. Never mind devising a solution for a theoretical Iraq, don’t you need one for an actual Iraq transformed by major trauma?
(Will the Kurds be saying "Look at them crazy A-rabs down south! We don’t want no part of that!")
Just trying to cheer you up while you wait for Iraq’s real election results tomorrow.
 
_____________________________________________________________________

I think the cronyism is Iraq is less because the Americans are used to using it in foreign countries, and more because 30 years of Saddam taught local politicians that that was the normal and expected mode of operation.

Abu, you place too much blame for inept governence on the US, and too little on the legacy of Baath party rule. Only Iraqis can fix Iraq. Iraqis are going to have to do some self-examination and confront some ingrained attitudes that are stumbling blocks to democracy. You can't just curse the US and absolve yourselves of blame.
 
_____________________________________________________________________

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
 
_____________________________________________________________________

Hello Abu Khaleel,
Waiting for election results. There is great intensity here and determination to see that justice is done. Foolish Bush may be history(God willing).
But the suffering of the Iraqis is not over.
 
_____________________________________________________________________

"Many obnoxious systems of government loyal or friendly to the US are regarded as tolerable and sometimes even good."

Our standards are not even that high. The picture that sticks in my mind is from the 1980's when Donald Rumsfeld was shaking the hand of Saddam Hussien -- a case of a government that was repulsive yet doing something the US supported and thus had our support.
 
_____________________________________________________________________

Nice blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you! I have a work at home data entry position
site. It pretty much covers work at home data entry position
related stuff.

Come and check it out if you get time :-)
 
_____________________________________________________________________

Nice Blog!!!   I thought I'd tell you about a site that will let give you places where
you can make extra cash! I made over $800 last month. Not bad for not doing much. Just put in your
zip code and up will pop up a list of places that are available. I live in a small area and found quite
a few. MAKE MONEY NOW
 
_____________________________________________________________________

Appreciated your thoughts.

Steve @
LifeIncome
 
_____________________________________________________________________

Online poker - Free 50 dollars bankrolls for new players
No deposit needed poker money bonuses

El Chupacabras
 
_____________________________________________________________________

Oes Tsetnoc one of the ways in which we can learn seo besides Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa. By participating in the Oes Tsetnoc or Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa we can improve our seo skills. To find more information about Oest Tsetnoc please visit my Oes Tsetnoc pages. And to find more information about Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa please visit my Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa pages. Thank you So much.
Oes Tsetnoc | Semangat Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa
 
_____________________________________________________________________

One of your articles is good but other are average. Your blog is good anyway.
--------------------------
Sans Depot
Poker Money
In addition to poker and tennis Patrik Antonius loves workouts at the gym and all physical activity. Leading a healthy lifestyle and very respectful of their figure by training every day, taking vitamins and other poker supplements. This is another player of great caliber, which points out that to have a good and continuously play poker need good physical and mental condition. However, Patrik never denied himself a few beers at a party and how to tell his friends about it, overall this is a man who likes to have a free poker bonus.
Full Tilt Sin Deposito
Ohne Einzahlung
Let us therefore concludes Caesar what belongs to Caesar. Finn because of its appearance is the idol of women. Aggressive style and results inspire admiration among poker players making Antonius can be considered a true poker star. It is not surprising that it is desirable for all kinds of media and is often invited to many TV programs, not just poker. If you are in the world of poker equivalent of a David Beckham, it is certainly the first candidate for this comparison is free poker money.
instant money
Titan Poker Capitale

 
_____________________________________________________________________

This is one of the most interesting articles since few months on your blog. Congratulations dear admin.
-----------------------------------
Poker deposito
Bonus depot
Carefully choose the initial two cards (starting capital), do not be tempted to play too many hands. If you hit your weak hand and examine the situation that you are worse than your opponent card system - fit (fold). Not worth playing each card. Poker is not just your card - it is also an opponent and his cards. Do not play the king of four only because the king is a strong card. Wait until the king comes with another king or an ace. Then aggressively enter the game! At the beginning of the Hold 'em limit your hands with which you enter the awards to: AA, KK, QQ, AK, AQ, AJ, JJ, 10-10. Over time, as experience is gained, you can expand your range of hands.
To sum up - play by a simple rule - only enter with strong cards and if you have a good hand firmly place poker money! Bluffs and sharp piercing leave professionals. Just so you have a chance to be one of them.
bono por registro
kapital ohne einzahlung
Carefully watch your opponents play, determine how they represent their style of texas holdem play - it'll help you to make informed decisions. Whether they are careful but aggressive players (tight-aggressive), or on the contrary, you are dealing with an aggressive maniac (loose-aggresive), who regardless of their card raises the stakes. Poker is not just our cards - this is reading your opponents, their behavior and try to estimate their cards. If you accurately determine who you play bonuses, you will have fun this game and increase your chances of winning.
Properly manage its own budget (bankroll management).
Skilful manage your budget with a few simple rules. When you play at the tables 0.5 / $ 1 Fixed Limit, your budget is a minimum of $ 300, preferably $ 500. When you lose, do not try to make up for losses, end the poker game. When you lose what you have earned before, go back to the lower limit and win up again, you'll be able to play on the tables with a higher limit.
Poker in Europe
Sign up Poker

 
_____________________________________________________________________
Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Listed on Blogwise